2. Appointment of a Recorder: Faye Christenberry, outgoing Chair of the DG was appointed recorder of the meeting.
3. News and Updates from the MLA: Terry Ford, Director of the
Center for
Bibliographic Services & Editor:
-There was great concern over a price increase for those who
access MLA IB through
FirstSearch. OCLC felt they needed to increase the subscription
cost approximately 40%
and decided to spread it out over a two-year period. People should
expect to see another
increase next year.
- SilverPlatter has agreed to make an electronic version of the
Directory of Periodicals
available. This may increase the subscription price slightly, but
they will not charge an
additional fee for the Directory.
- MLA received a large grant from the Mellon Foundation to support
four projects:
Susanna Pathak, MLA Advisory Board:
Because Susanna was unable to attend, Terry gave a brief update on
the activities of the
Advisory Board. In the fall, the group will vote on the question
of whether or not the
MLA IB should continue to index collections of essays by a single
author.
4. Availability Issues Concerning the "Report of the MLA
Bibliography Scope & Overlap
Committee, and ACRL Ad Hoc Committee:" (Scott Stebelman)
Because Scott was unable to make it to the meeting, Faye
Christenberry asked the group
how they felt about making this document (ED417730, 215 pages)
more accessible.
Should it be available full-text on the web? If so, who should be
responsible? Most
members of the group felt web access would be advantageous, if it
were clearly stated
that the information was outdated. Someone suggested we consider
updating the reports
on a regular basis. Finally, most agreed that there should be
links to information about the
document through the EALS website and the MLA IB Discussion Group
website.
5. Comparative Analysis of ABELL and the MLA IB: (Scott
Stebelman)
As Scott was unable to attend the meeting, he did not present his
findings to the group.
Because there was interest in hearing his report, Scott will be
contacted to present at the
Midwinter meeting. It was suggested that anyone interested in
doing a comparative
analysis could do so and report back to the group at Midwinter.
Further, a specific
methodology should be used, so that the results would be more
consistent. Terry Ford
suggested that the findings would be more useful to MLA if certain
subject areas were
targeted. Terry will contact Susan Peters with this information
and she will post it on the listserv.
6. New Business:
- Election of a Chair-Elect: Due to low turnout at this meeting,
it was decided that the
election of a Chair-Elect would be held during the Midwinter
meeting in San Antonio.
- People unanimously agreed that moving the meeting back to the
regular time slot
(Saturday mornings) would be preferable.
6. Topics for Discussion Group Meeting (ALA Midwinter, San
Antonio):
- Comparative analysis of MLA IB & ABELL (see 5. Above)
- Contact representatives from OCLC, OVID, & SilverPlatter and
have them meet with
the group to discuss pricing issues for MLA IB - Print versus
paper edition of the MLA
IB: advantages & disadvantages of both formats. Terry Ford
suggested that this topic be
tabled for the Annual meeting in Chicago, when a representative
from MLA could attend
and participate in the discussion.
Respectfully submitted,
Faye Christenberry
University of Kansas